Is the Blue Cash Preferred still worth $95 a year?

At renewal there's no welcome bonus left, just the fee against what the card earns and the credits you actually use. Here's that renewal year for three spending profiles, compared with downgrading or switching to a no-fee card. Terms verified Oct 5, 2026.

Profile	Blue Cash Preferred after fee	Best alternative	Pays	Verdict
Everyday spender About $2,000 a month, mostly groceries and errands, one trip a year.	$474	Freedom Flex	$495	Close call
Balanced About $3,500 a month with a few trips a year and regular dining out.	$752	Wells Fargo Autograph	$811	Cancel or downgrade Keep only if its unpriced perks are worth over $60 a year to you.
Frequent traveler About $5,000 a month, heavy on flights, hotels and restaurants, some trips abroad.	$857	Wells Fargo Autograph	$1,370	Cancel or downgrade Keep only if its unpriced perks are worth over $513 a year to you.

Profiles use typed totals, so merchant credits (rideshare, delivery, streaming) aren't counted here.Answer a few questions in the calculator below and the verdict updates.

The credits, and what it takes to use them

Up to $120 a year on paper. They only offset the fee to the extent you'd have spent that money anyway.

Credit	How it works
$120 Disney Streaming Credit ($10 a month)	Up to $10 a month on subscriptions (including bundles) bought on the U.S. websites DisneyPlus.com, Hulu.com or Stream.ESPN.com; auto-renewing. No minimum spend. An annual subscription earns only one $10 credit. Raised from $7 to $10 a month on 2025-08-01. Needs enrollment.

Run it on your own spending

The calculator needs JavaScript. The table above is precomputed.

Downgrade instead of closing: American Express usually lets you product-change to the Blue Cash Everyday, which keeps your account age and credit line. Ask before you cancel.

Compare: Blue Cash Everyday vs Blue Cash Preferred · Blue Cash Preferred vs Costco Anywhere Visa